Current:Home > FinanceA Georgia trial arguing redistricting harmed Black voters could decide control of a US House seat -Wealth Evolution Experts
A Georgia trial arguing redistricting harmed Black voters could decide control of a US House seat
View
Date:2025-04-14 21:39:44
ATLANTA (AP) — Democrats could gain a seat in the U.S. House and multiple seats in Georgia’s Legislature if a judge rules Republicans drew maps illegally weakening Black voters’ power.
The trial beginning Tuesday is part of a wave of litigation progressing after the U.S. Supreme Court earlier this year stood behind its interpretation of the Voting Rights Act, rejecting Alabama’s challenge to the law.
The Voting Rights Act says voting district lines can’t result in discriminatory effects against minority voters, who must be allowed a chance to elect candidates of their choosing.
Court cases challenging district lines drawn after the 2020 Census could shape 2024 congressional elections in states beyond Alabama and Georgia, including Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina and Texas. Taken as a whole, those cases could affect the narrow hold Republicans have on the U.S. House.
In Georgia, U.S. District Judge Steve Jones is hearing what is expected to be a two-week case without a jury. If he rules against the state, he is likely to order Georgia’s Republican-controlled General Assembly to redraw districts to comply with the law.
The trial yokes together three different cases, meaning Jones could rule for the challengers in some instances and not others.
Jones already ruled in March 2022 that some parts of Georgia’s redistricting plans probably violate federal law. He allowed the new congressional and state legislative maps to be used for 2022’s elections, finding changes close to elections would have been too disruptive.
Charles Bullock, a University of Georgia political scientist who studies redistricting, said he expects Jones to side with the plaintiffs.
“He found the plaintiffs had proven the elements of a Section 2 violation at that point,” Bullock said of the earlier ruling.
The plaintiffs challenging the districts argue there is room to draw another Black-majority congressional seat on the west side of metro Atlanta, as well as three more majority-Black state Senate districts and five additional majority-Black state house districts in various parts of the state. They point to Georgia’s addition of a half million Black residents from 2010 to 2020, nearly half of all population growth.
“Despite these striking demographic changes, the enacted congressional plan fails to reflect the growth in Georgia’s Black population,” the plaintiffs challenging Georgia’s congressional map wrote in a summary of their case filed with the court.
The state, though, argues the plaintiffs haven’t proved voters act the way they do because of race, arguing partisanship is a stronger motivator.
Defense attorneys, for example, point to the role of partisanship in the original election of Democratic U.S. Rep. Lucy McBath in 2018. McBath, who is Black, first won office in a district with a small Black population. Lawmakers then redrew lines to make the district significantly more Republican, leading McBath to jump to and win reelection in a different district.
The state also argues plaintiffs would rely so much on race to draw districts that it would be illegal.
“That’s a defense you can offer is what the plaintiffs want would require putting considerations of race above everything else,” Bullock said.
But Kareem Crayton, senior director for voting and representation at New York University’s Brennan Center for Justice, said Georgia’s claims that lawmakers didn’t consider race in drawing lines, only partisanship, should lead to questions about whether they considered if the lines discriminated.
“It sounds like, so far, the state is saying, ‘We don’t talk about race at all.’ But then, is there a story to be told about?” Crayton said. “What does it mean to have a significant portion of your state that has not been able to access power?”
Republicans held an 8-6 majority in Georgia’s U.S. House delegation in 2020, but majority-GOP state lawmakers redrew lines to eliminate one of those Democratic seats, boosting their majority to 9-5. If the plaintiffs win, the balance could revert to 8-6 Republicans. However, lawmakers also could try to convert McBath’s current seat into a majority Black seat.
The GOP currently holds a 102-78 majority in the state House and a 33-23 majority in the state Senate. While a plaintiff’s victory is unlikely to flip control in either chamber, additional Black-majority districts in the Senate and House could elect Democrats who would narrow Republican margins.
veryGood! (121)
Related
- Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
- Tom Brady roast on Netflix: 12 best burns* of NFL legend, Bill Belichick and Patriots
- Long Beach shooting injures 7, 4 critically wounded, police say
- All 9 Drake and Kendrick Lamar 2024 diss songs, including 'Not Like Us' and 'Part 6'
- Justice Department, Louisville reach deal after probe prompted by Breonna Taylor killing
- Trump Media fires auditing firm that US regulators have charged with ‘massive fraud’
- Commercial jet maker Airbus is staying humble even as Boeing flounders. There’s a reason for that
- Ex-U.K. leader Boris Johnson turned away from polling station for forgetting photo ID under law he ushered in
- The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
- 'Monster' Billy Crystal looks back on life's fastballs, curveballs and Joe DiMaggio
Ranking
- Friday the 13th luck? 13 past Mega Millions jackpot wins in December. See top 10 lottery prizes
- Kim Godwin out as ABC News president after 3 years as first Black woman as network news chief
- Children are dying of fentanyl by the dozens in Missouri. A panel is calling for changes
- Why Ryan Gosling Avoids Darker Roles for the Sake of His Family
- Senate begins final push to expand Social Security benefits for millions of people
- Gap Factory's Sale Is Up to 75% Off & The Deals Will Have You Clicking Add To Cart ASAP
- The Best Throwback Celebrity Cameos to Give You Those Nostalgia Vibes
- The Bachelorette's Desiree Hartsock Is Pregnant, Expecting Baby No. 3 With Husband Chris Siegfried
Recommendation
Don't let hackers fool you with a 'scam
Queen Rania of Jordan says U.S. is seen as enabler of Israel
Amazing: Kyle Larson edges Chris Buescher at Kansas in closest finish in NASCAR history
The Deeply Disturbing True Story Behind Baby Reindeer
Highlights from Trump’s interview with Time magazine
Music legends celebrate 'The Queens of R&B Tour' in Las Vegas
Anna Wintour Holds Court at the 2024 Met Gala in a Timeless Silhouette
Brian Austin Green’s Ex Vanessa Marcil Slams “Stupid” Criticism Aimed at Megan Fox